(M.J.E. / Writings / Book Reviews / Children's Fiction /
Blyton / Famous Five / 5 Billycock)

Enid BLYTON: 16. Five Go to Billycock Hill (1957)

Review by Michael Edwards - also appears on Amazon.co.uk

Appears on Amazon.co.uk:
    Date : 26 August, 1999
    Rating : 4/5
    Heading : Slightly tame and less focused Famous Five adventure.

      The Five go cycling over to camp on Billycock Hill, close to the farm where a friend, Toby, lives. Also nearby is the butterfly farm owned by Mr. Gringle and Mr. Brent, where everything just doesn't seem quite right: the two butterfly experts are themselves strange, and one doesn't seem to recognize a Fritillary, and goes moth-hunting on a stormy night when no moths would be around; also, old Mrs. Janes who lives there seems constantly afraid of what her "bad" son will do if strangers visit the farm.
      There are other strange events, too. For instance, the Billycock Caves are nearby, and the children go exploring, only to come bolting out in panic after hearing strange noises in distant caves.
      Nearby is a military airfield which is thrown into disarray that same stormy night that Mr. Brent was out moth-hunting, when two top-secret experimental aircraft are stolen and flown overseas, one apparently piloted by Toby's cousin, Jeff, who seemed so decent and admirable to everyone, especially the doting Toby, that surely he couldn't be a traitor to his own country? But he and a colleague are the only airmen on the airfield who are missing, so the evidence seems pretty conclusive.
      The Five and Toby investigate, thinking that maybe these disparate strange events are related somehow; they focus their attention on the butterfly farm, which seems to be at the centre of things, and a plot gradually emerges, and everything eventually falls into place, with a few shocks and surprises along the way.

      While this story is quite engrossing, as are all the Famous Five books, and contains its share of surprises and revelations, it seems less exciting, and the plot a bit less focused, than many of the other Famous Five books. The children barely come into contact with their opposition, if you don't count the enigmatic butterfly men, who may or may not be real antagonists, and certainly not the main ones; the only contact with anyone more sinister than the butterfly men occurs in one brief burst, unlike most of the other Famous Five books, where the conflict between the two sides is usually far more direct, and much longer. This remoteness of the real antagonists probably accentuates the effect the story gives of being less exciting, less focused. The story itself seems rather episodic, not building up momentum in the same inexorable way that some of the other stories do. It might be a flaw that the most exciting moment just referred to comes several chapters before the end of the book. And it is only a moment, not several chapters long like many other Famous Five climaxes, and it is less exciting than most of those other climaxes even while it lasts.
      Also, a significant flaw in the nuts and bolts of the plot is where the two stolen planes crash into the sea, killing the two pilots (extremely rare instances of death occurring in Enid Blyton's novels, albeit off-stage). Unless the planes were sabotaged (which was not mentioned, and wouldn't fit in with the plot), it just lacks credibility that two planes should crash (presumably accidentally) at the same time, and even the fact that it was a stormy night does not seem sufficient explanation, although you are left to presume that the storm did it, because no explanation was given for why the planes crashed. (I suppose the storm could do it, if it was extremely severe - but it didn't seem that severe.)
      Those negative things said, the book is certainly as readable as any of the other Famous Five books, and you do keep reading to find out what happened - especially if you are indulging in a little nostalgia and reading it again for the first time in perhaps 35 years, as I did recently, and have forgotten most of the details of the plot.

Michael Edwards,
Victoria, Australia.

E-mail me about this book.

      Click here if you need an explanation for the strange appearance of the e-mail address which will appear when you click on the e-mail link, or if you don't know what you need to do to make the e-mail address work properly.

Original text copyright (C) 1999, 2000, by Michael Edwards.

More material on this web site related to Blyton

      Book listing for Enid Blyton

      More reviews by myself of Enid Blyton's books

Further links

      Amazon.com customer reviews

      Amazon.co.uk customer reviews

    Introduction - Front page, which leads to Contents
    Web Site of Michael Edwards - Contents

Site Map
    Writings by Michael Edwards
        Book reviews
            Children's Fiction
                Enid Blyton
                    Famous Five Books
                        16. Five Go to Billycock Hill (this page)

This page created on Friday, 12 May, 2000;
last modified on Thursday, 15 June, 2000.